**Kylebooker Seals Fur Substitute Dubbing for Fly Tying – Pk of 24 – Cumbria Fishing: Is It Worth the Money?**
For fly-tying enthusiasts, selecting the right dubbing material is crucial for creating effective and lifelike flies. The **Kylebooker Seals Fur Substitute Dubbing** (Pack of 24) has gained attention among anglers, especially those fishing in Cumbria’s renowned waters. But does it offer good value for money? Let’s break down its features, performance, and overall cost-effectiveness.
### **What Is Kylebooker Seals Fur Substitute Dubbing?**
This synthetic dubbing is designed to mimic the texture and appearance of natural seal fur, a prized material in fly tying due to its ability to trap air and create buoyant, shimmering flies. The pack includes **24 assorted colors**, making it versatile for imitating various insects and baitfish. It’s marketed as an ethical and affordable alternative to real seal fur, appealing to environmentally conscious anglers.
### **Performance and Quality**
1. **Texture & Workability**
– The fibers are fine and slightly sticky, allowing for easy application on the thread.
– Unlike some synthetic dubbings that clump or shed, this product blends smoothly, producing a natural-looking fly body.
– It holds well when wound, reducing the need for excessive waxing.
2. **Buoyancy & Durability**
– While not as buoyant as real seal fur, it performs admirably in dry flies and emergers.
– The material resists waterlogging better than cheaper synthetics, making it suitable for nymphs and wet flies too.
3. **Color Retention**
– The hues remain vibrant even after prolonged use, an advantage over lower-grade substitutes that fade quickly.
### **Price vs. Competitors**
At around **£12–£15 per pack (24 colors)**, Kylebooker’s offering is competitively priced. Compared to natural seal fur (which can cost **£5–£10 per gram**), this substitute is a budget-friendly option. Even against other synthetic brands like **Hareline or Wapsi**, it holds its own in terms of color variety and texture.
### **Who Should Buy It?**
– **Beginners**: The color assortment allows experimentation without a hefty investment.
– **Ethical Anglers**: A cruelty-free alternative to traditional seal fur.
– **Budget-Conscious Tyers**: Delivers decent quality at a reasonable price.
### **Potential Drawbacks**
– **Not 100% Natural Feel**: Purists might still prefer real fur for its superior floatation.
– **Limited Bulk Options**: Buying individual colors could be more cost-effective for advanced tyers.
### **Final Verdict: Good Value for Money**
For **Cumbria fishing**—where mayflies, caddis, and midges dominate—this dubbing provides a practical, affordable solution. While it doesn’t fully replicate premium materials, its **balance of price, quality, and versatility** makes it a solid choice for most fly tyers. **Rating: 4/5**.
Would you try it? Tight lines! 🎣