**The Value and Appeal of *Kylebooker Fly Tying* by William Bayard Sturgis (1940 Illustrated First Edition Hardback)**
For fishing enthusiasts and collectors of angling literature, *Kylebooker Fly Tying* by William Bayard Sturgis is a rare gem. Published in 1940 as a first-edition hardback with illustrations, this book holds historical significance and practical value for fly-tying aficionados. But how does it measure up in terms of cost-effectiveness? Let’s explore its merits, rarity, and whether it’s worth the investment.
### **Historical and Practical Significance**
William Bayard Sturgis was a respected figure in fly fishing, and *Kylebooker Fly Tying* is one of his notable contributions. The book provides detailed instructions on creating classic fly patterns, many of which remain relevant today. For modern anglers, the techniques and designs in this book offer a glimpse into traditional fly-tying methods, making it both an educational resource and a collector’s item.
The 1940 first edition is particularly prized because it captures the essence of early 20th-century fly fishing. The illustrations add significant value, as they visually guide readers through intricate tying processes. Unlike later reprints, the original edition carries an authenticity that appeals to purists.
### **Rarity and Collectibility**
Given its age, the first edition of *Kylebooker Fly Tying* is relatively scarce. Books from this era, especially in good condition, are highly sought after by collectors. Factors affecting its price include:
– **Condition:** A well-preserved copy with an intact dust jacket commands a premium.
– **Provenance:** Copies signed by Sturgis or with historical annotations are exceptionally valuable.
– **Demand:** Fly-fishing literature has a niche but dedicated market, and early editions often appreciate over time.
Current market prices for this book vary widely. While later reprints or damaged copies may sell for under $100, a pristine first edition can fetch several hundred dollars or more, depending on demand.
### **Cost-Effectiveness: Is It Worth It?**
For **serious collectors**, the book is undoubtedly worth the investment. Its historical importance and scarcity make it a centerpiece in any angling library. If you appreciate vintage fishing literature, owning a first edition is akin to possessing a piece of angling history.
For **practical anglers**, the value depends on your goals. If you’re looking for modern fly-tying techniques, newer books or digital resources may be more up-to-date. However, if you enjoy traditional methods or want to study the evolution of fly patterns, *Kylebooker Fly Tying* offers timeless insights.
### **Alternatives and Considerations**
If budget is a concern, consider:
– **Later editions or reprints**, which are more affordable but lack the collectible appeal.
– **Digital scans** (if available), though they don’t replicate the tactile experience of an old hardback.
– **Modern fly-tying guides**, which may be more practical for everyday use.
### **Final Verdict**
The 1940 first edition of *Kylebooker Fly Tying* is a worthwhile investment for collectors and traditionalists. Its blend of historical significance, practical knowledge, and aesthetic charm justifies its price for those who value rare angling literature. However, casual anglers might prefer more contemporary resources. If you find a well-priced copy in good condition, it could be a prized addition to your fishing library—one that may even appreciate in value over time.
For those who cherish the heritage of fly fishing, this book isn’t just a tool; it’s a legacy.